Shadow Play 4×20

I wasn’t sure I’d be into a concept episode – but this weird drug fantasy of Spencer ended up being pretty cool.

PLL Mona mirrors 4x20

This shot of Mona is menacing and awesome.


PLL red jacket 4x20

This is her “sometimes villans win” speech which gives us so many A tingles. 5/10

PLL Aria black and white striped dress 4x20

So flattering. 7/10

PLL Aria big plaid jacket 4x20

Biggest plaid pattern we’ve seen on the show 6/10

PLL Aria leopard print skirt black tank 4x20

Wish we could get a better look at this sexy number 6/10


PLL Blue and white vest 4x20

80s throwback, in the best way 8/10

PLL Emily gems 4x20

Never seen her dripping in so many gems 8/10


PLL Hanna hot pink black lace dress 4x20

I hate having to repeat myself about hot pink and black lace, yet here we are again. 4/10

PLL Hanna puffy polka dot 4x20

Makeup A+, puffy top C = 5/10

PLL Hanna beret 4x20

I would watch a rear window remake with Hanna in a heartbeat 10/10


PLL Spencer deer sweater 4x20

So many animal sweaters, so little time. 4/10

PLL Spencer black and white fantasy 4x20

Can I get whatever she’s on? 6/10

PLL Spencer silk dressing gown 4x20

All in favor of floor length silk dressing gowns making a comeback. 7/10

PLL Spencer fur neck jacket 4x20

From Russia, with love. 5/10

PLL Spencer skirt suit 4x20

Girl loves a good skirt suit. 5/10

PLL Spencer sheer white top 4x20

Proof everything looks better in black and white 9/10

PLL Spencer blue peter pan collar 4x20

Era appropriate collar for her coming out of her fantasy sequence 6/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 6/10
Emily: 8/10
Hanna: 6.1/10
Spencer: 6/10

Side note: Spencer is just taking adderall right? They are acting like she’s on LSD and it’s a little odd…

PLL Ali glam 4x20

So glam

PLL Ali stripper 4x10

Is Ali a stripper in Spencer’s fantasy? LOL


Hot For Teacher 4×19

Ezra has really amped up his creeping and sweeps Aria away to the cabin with no cell service or access… *where no one can hear you scream* Meanwhile Spencer is starting to slip further down into her drug spiral.


PLL Aria leia hair 4x19

Leia hair can’t distract us from those cute lace cut outs 8/10

PLL Aria bird necklace 4x19

You’re a free bird, so fly. Far, far away from Fitz. 6/10

PLL Aria lace floral top 4x19

Gosh I hope Ezra doesn’t keep you trapped in this cabin with that awful lace floral top. 5/10

PLL Aria black nightgown 4x19

Are nightgowns a thing again? 4/10


PLL Emily sheer sweater 4x19

Emily’s new commitment to sheer tops is admirable 7/10

PLL Emily wine draped dress 4x19

Wishing for a better neckline to go with the great bottom draping 7/10

PLL Emily allergic to mornings 4x19

You and me both girl. 5/10

PLL Emily lumberjack 4x19

Lumberjack chic 6/10

PLL Emily black tank 4x19

Think she ever gets cold arms? 4/10


PLL Hanna paint top 4x19

Like a painting 6/10

PLL Hanna red blazer black heels 4x19

Full on shoe-gasming while Holbrook watches. I don’t think he minds. 7/10

PLL Hanna white lace pants 4x19



PLL Spencer blue button up 4x19

Doing her best stewardess impression 4/10

PLL Spencer soft long sleeve 4x19

I can practically feel how soft this is through the screen. 6/10

PLL Spencer dark green button up 4x19

Strung out Spence is starting to bum us out… 4/10

PLL Spencer brown distressed bag 4x19

Really into this distressed bag 9/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 5.75/10
Emily: 5.8/10
Hanna: 7/10
Spencer: 5.75/10

Druggie Spencer’s wardrobe is really suffering, but Hanna is holding the bar up high.

Bite Your Tongue 4×18

A goes crazy this episode and performs dentAl surgery on Hanna and Spencer goes full on Nancy drew to find out about the Ezra of it all.

PLL Mike and Mona 4x18

Watch out – Rosewood’s got a new power couple!


PLL Aria black and white checked shirt 4x18

Looks like the floor of a 50s diner 5/10

PLL Aria blue dress 4x18

 Remember kids scissors that cut strips of different shapes? 6/10

PLL Black rose pants 4x18

Help! She’s being swallowed whole by a Hot Topic. 3/10


PLL Emily lightning tee 4x18

Straight people *smh* 6/10

PLL Emily bedazzled plaid 4x18

Don’t try to bedazzle your plaid. Just… don’t. 2/10

PLL Emily patriotic tee 4x18

Not very patriotic to nearly stab your dad with scissors! 5/10

PLL Emily white lattice top 4x18

Lattice wear – so in right now 7/10


PLL Hanna teal tee 4x18

Hanna should wear teal more often. 6/10

PLL Hanna tan belted jacket 4x18

This jacket is everything. 9/10

PLL Hanna pink silk PJs 4x18

A girls gotta have her favorite PJs 7/10

PLL Hanna blue camo dress 4x18

Tell me thats not blue camo – please, please no. 4/10

PLL Hanna dentist 4x18

This A is FUCKED. UP.


PLL Spencer striped sweatshirt 4x18

That embroidered triangle screams LL Bean 5/10

PLL Spencer cropped jeans 4x18

So casual, so cool 6/10

PLL Spencer cozy hoodie 4x18

Cozy hoodie is perfect for a 4 am wake-up call 5/10

PLL Spencer pink tank 4x18

Our little J.Crew princess has gone full Free People 4/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 4.3/10
Emily: 5/10
Hanna: 6.5/10
Spencer: 5/10

PLL Board Shorts Ale 4x18

Ezra is board shorts!?

Close Encounters 4×17

Ali reaches out to Emily which turns Spencer into an over-controlling monster and Aria must choose between creepy Ezra or smoking hot Jake. Her life is so hard.


PLL Aria pebbles dress 4x17

Pebbles Flintstone 4/10


PLL Emily maroon jacket 4x17

Since when is her letterman’s jacket maroon? 7/10

PLL Emily grey jacket 4x17

Functional but still cute for a clandestine meeting with your former flame. 7/10


PLL Hanna creepin 4x17

You should be handing this shirt off to Ezra. #creeping 6/10

PLL Hanna sheer top red skirt

Good call Hanna, pool in a short skirt is a great flirting method. 6/10

PLL Hanna lipstick tank 4x17

Even sad Hanna puts her face on. 6/10

PLL Hanna black flower sweater 4x17

Just incase you needed a reminder that Hanna and Ashley are perfect. (Hate to do this but Hanna’s sweater is a 4/10)


PLL Spencer toby's boxers 4x17

Toby’s boxers: a father’s worst nightmare 4/10

PLL Spencer giraffe sweater 4x17

She could open a zoo at this point. 6/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 4/10
Emily: 7/10
Hanna: 5.4/10
Spencer: 5/10

PLL Jake shirtless 4x17

She DIDN’T pick this… further proof that Aria is crazy.

PLL knife punching bag 4x17

What did this even accomplish? The show is trying so hard to prove Ezra is A but we just aren’t buying it.

Love ShAck, Baby 4×16

Caleb is gone to Ravenswood now – counting the days until he comes back! In the meantime we have to deal with Hanna being wooed by Travis.


PLL Aria leopard pants 4x16

Rock ‘n Roll 7/10


PLL Emily green tee 4x16

Green looks good with her new(ish) ombre hair color 6/10

PLL Emily blue tank top 4x16

An unwelcome return to basics 5/10

PLL Emily mauve jacket 4x16

Waiting for Ali looks good on Em 7/10


PLL Hanna braided hair 4x16

Hanna Marin is gorgeous appreciation post.

PLL Hanna blue fuzzy jacket 4x16

No to this jacket, no to Travis. 5/10

PLL Hefty pink blazer 4x16

Ali is such a bitch. In a world without her, we could have a Hefty+Mike relationship right now which we totally ship. 5/10


PLL Spencer khaki cape 4x16

The cape is incredible, the suspenders are ridiculous. We’re all confused about what to rate this outfit. 7/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 7/10
Emily: 6/10
Hanna: 5/10
Spencer: 7/10

A pretty strong showing from everyone this week, but we still can’t get a feel for what Ezra is up to other than being a shady little asshole.


Who’s in the Box? 4×15

The girls are finally sure that Ali is alive and are kind of… eh about it to be honest. The most fun part of the pisode is the show’s insistance on making Ezra look CRAZY now that we know he’s not exactly who he claims to be.


PLL Aria gold heart 4x15

Heart of gold 6/10

PLL Aria denim jacket 4x15

I can’t believe I miss her distressed denim jacket 4/10

PLL Aria galaxy pants 4x15

You can go stargazing in Aria’s pants. [insert dirty joke here] 6/10

PLL Aria black dress feathers 4x15

Black Swan 2.0 casual wear 7/10

PLL Aria baby pastels 4x15

It looks like a baby shower threw up on her 3/10


PLL Emily grey sleeveless sweatshirt 4x15

“Listen guys – you dont need sleeves! It’s better without them!” 5/10

PLL Emily sporty black and white jacket  4x15

Spice it up a little Em. 5/10

PLL Emily black sporty dress 4x15

Leg envy is strong with Em around 6/10

PLL Emily blue shirt 4x15

“Budget Em stole my plaid” – Emily inner monologue 4/10

PLL Emily skull white shirt 4x15

Did Aria say you could wear skulls? You need to ask first. 6/10

PLL Emily grey vest 4x15



PLL Hanna black tee 4x15

Ali would be disappointed 4/10

PLL Hanna 60s mod purple 4x15

Hanna strides purposely out of an Austin Powers scene 3/10

PLL Hanna purple fur 4x15

Even Aria thinks this is ridiculous 2×10

PLL Hanna light blue dress

Making those blue eyes pop! 6/10

PLL Hanna gumdrop tee 4x15

You think she keeps those to eat off her shoulder? 5×10

PLL Hanna light blue jacket 4x15

Have we seen this jacket before? It seems familiar, like something we tried to block out. 4/10

PLL Hanna blue pants 4x15

What you aren’t seeing in this picture is how puffy her blue pants are. Circus tent puffy. 5/10

PLL Aria blue green skirt 4x15

Vera Bradley makes skirts now? 5/10


PLL Spencer black henley 4x15

Spence least of all can hide her disappointment in Ali being home. 4/10

PLL Spencer rose sweater 4x15

Roses are red, violets are blue, this sweater sucks 4/10

PLL Spencer red pants 4x15

It’s always weird when Spencer is the worst dressed in the group of these three. 5/10

PLL Spencer green top 4x15

Woe is the hospital owner who messes with Spencer in her power suit 7/10

PLL Spencer blue dress grey blazer 4x15

I’m not going to lie – it looks like dinosaurs on her dress and I like it. 7/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 5.2/10
Emily: 4.8/10
Hanna: 4.2/10
Spencer: 5.2/10

Season premieres are always so full of costume changes, this one was no exception. What a great start to season 4B!

PLL Fake Emily and Hanna 4x15

Budget Emily and Hanna are freaking me out.

Grave New World 4×14 (Halloween Special)

Halloween time and we’re stuck in Ravenswood. This is for sure the worst Halloween special of the series – but let’s dive in.

PLL Ezra gas mask 4x14

Love a man in uniform…


PLL Aria madhatter 4x14

Why is Aria dressed like the Madhatter? 4/10


PLL Emily 20s pimp 4x14

Why is Emily dressed like a 1920s pimp? 3/10


PLL Hanna daisy 4x14

Why is Hanna dressed like Daisy Buchanan? (her boobs look great though) 5/10


PLL Spencer roses mom titanic 4x14

Why is Spencer dressed like Rose’s mom from titanic? 2/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 3/10
Emily: 3/10
Hanna: 5/10
Spencer: 2/10

What. was. that. We’re going to chalk this up to being Ravenwood’s fault and just move on.

PLL Ali alive 4x14

FINALLY Ali is 100% confirmed alive. Hey girl.