If First You Don’t Succeed, Lie, Lie Again 1×15

Aria goes on a very special date and we are introduced to Paige and her awful haircut. As the plot picks up, so do the fashion choices.

Aria

Of course Aria wears funky beanies at sleepovers. 5/10

I too went through a stud phase. These are pretty gracefully done. 7/10

I’m completely opposed to Ezria – but this scene was really cute.

Aria! So adorable! 7/10

When she wants to dress up… WOW. 9/10

Just because.

Am I getting desensitized to Aria fashion? 5/10

Emily

“Should we try to make Emily more ‘butch’? Let’s use this as an experiment.” Failed. 4/10

Swimming is so hard to pull off on screen. The PLL team doesn’t do it half bad. This suit is pretty accurate, but at practice we wear bright colors and layers. 6/10

Too distracted by Paige’s haircut to give this outfit any kind of real score. 5/10

We’ve been waiting 15 episodes for something like this from Emily. Killer boots, great colors, just so much better than normal. 8/10

All black is very appropriate when you’re finding our one of your best friend’s is about to become a big red herring. 6/10

Hanna

She is at her own admission tired and blah. We agree. 4/10

Enough with the ties. We’re done with those. Put it away. 4/10

This outfit looks GREAT here and then later we see it’s actually a maroon skirt and things start to fall apart. 6/10

In case you were wondering, the “necklace” is part of the shirt, bringing this to a weird place. 5/10

Spencer

*Adds fuzzy purple bathrobe to christmas list* 8/10

I need someone to explain this to me. I’m so puzzled. 2/10

Quick original Jason DiLaurentis appreciation interlude.

Lace looks good on Spence. So does loyalty and friendship! Great work this ep girl. 6/10 

I’m not going to sit through Pirates of the Caribbean without Orlando Bloom. I’m just not. 3/10

Episode Totals

Aria: 6.6
Emily: 5.8/10
Hanna: 4.75/10
Spencer: 4.75/10

Aria upped her game for the big date and Spencer falls from grace. Stop trying to make hats happen Spence, they’re not going to happen.